SVG & PNG Image Test

While I have yet to get my hands on either an iPad or Macbook Pro with a retina display, it’s clear that high resolution screens will be the standard in coming years. As such it’s imperative for designers to understand how to optimize images for these displays. The main technique being used so far is to basically build your images at 2x, then scale down using html. This is a fine technique, but since I’m now in the research phase, I thought I’d also give SVG a try. Below are the results of a quick run of tests and techniques using the Spigot logo. I chose it because 1. It’s a logo – something most websites will definitely want to optimize, and 2. It’s already a vector based graphic.

To see the effects, zoom in on the page. You can see the differences in sharpness compared to the original logo presented first below.

Original


Current logo, as of 7/13/2012. Looks all jaggy zoomed in, eh?

Test 1: SVG from Illustrator


File saved from Illustrator as .svg. The white background shape has an outer glow effect applied in Illustrator, but it’s not visible here for some reason. The logo looks very crisp when zoomed in, and the colors are exact. See how dark the spigot graphic is compared to the original above? It seems Photoshop changes it slightly when saved as a .png.

Test 2: SVG from Illustrator


File saved from Illustrator as .svg. Tried using an edited version of Illustrators bundled SVG outer glow effect, but it’s still not visible.

Test 3: SVG from Inkscape


When looking for .svg info on the web, there seemed to be more references to Inkscape, so I thought I’d export the file from there. Outer glow still not visible.

Test 4: SVG from Test 1 using <object>

Most of the .svg tutorials on the web stay to use <object> to output .svg files. This clearly isn’t working here and I’m not sure if this is more user error, a WordPress limitation, or otherwise. Either way, using <object> is a PITA compared to <img>.

Test 5: @2x PNG from Photoshop


Vector file imported into Photoshop, scaled up @2x, exported as .png, and scaled down via html. Zooming in looks pretty good. Not quite as crisp as .svg but the outer glow is there. The colors suffer the same issues as the original. Perhaps a Photoshop setting is incorrect somewhere?

Test 6: @2x PNG from Illustrator


File saved from Illustrator @2x, width scaled down via html. Since Illustrator can also output optimized .png files I thought I’d give it a go. Seems to have the same color issues as Photoshop, but looks crisp zoomed in.

Test 7: @3x PNG from Illustrator


Hey, if @2x is good, @3x must be better right? Nope. File saved from Illustrator @3x, scaled down via html.

Test 8: Hand optimized PNG


File saved from Photoshop @2x with the logotype hand optimized to reduce fuzzy anti-aliasing effects. The logotype is even crisper – note the slight fuzziness around the ‘P’ in some of the above files. This seems to be the way to go so far.

Conclustions

I’m far from being able to draw definite conclusions, but I didn’t have the luck I was hoping for with SVG. The outer glow effect I use wouldn’t translate through. It’s in the file, but something along the way is getting lost. This is most likely operator error, as .svg’s are probably not supposed to be added as an <img>. Bummer nonetheless. I was surprised to find that the colors were more true to original using .svg. I’d never really noticed that the current logo was even off. This is probably the reason I’ll continue looking to work .svg into our development.

I have yet to test browser support, but this post will allow for that – let me know what you’re seeing above when using something other than Safari on a Mac.

What I’ll be using for now: Test 8: Hand optimized @2x .png files from Photoshop.

Let me know what you think

I’d love to hear what others have experienced using .svg or @2x .png files. What am I missing?

8 Comments


Your \”Hand optimized PNG\” :-)
spigot-logo-test-8.png – 34,185 bytes
After tinypng.org – 14,532 bytes
After compresspng.com – 10,140 bytes (always better)

Reply

Ok I\’m convinced. The tools that Robin, Brian, and Pol have detailed are the right way to go.

Reply

Is it just me or are the images missing? I can\’t see any one of them.

Cheers

Reply

Outer glow working here as of 08/2014.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Check out our Complete Website Package

Chat with us about your project or click below to find out more!

Learn More   Chat with us

Hi. We are Spigot. Telemarketers pronounce it Spy-got.

We are a Park City, Utah based web design shop that excels at building custom websites powered by WordPress and WooCommerce. We love content - content strategy, content curation, content soup...????Have a look around the site. As you browse you'll find useful navigation links in the sidebar on the left. We hope you find them useful anyway... Please let us know what you think, shoot us a message here.